Creamcheese pops – My first Daring Bakers Challenge

My first Daring Bakers challenge – I am heaving a huge sigh of relief even as I am typing the text. Elle and Deborah were right when they said that for some it might be their first cheesecake! But what they did not mention was that for some it will also be their first making of creamcheese!! My reason for never attempting one – simple! I don’t get cream cheese in Thane!! I did not want to give that as a reason for not living upto the first challenge – so I literally started the recipe from the scratch!!!

First – I made the cream cheese by scouring the net for ages – looking for the best home made recipe. The first hurdle was that I do not use rennet as I am vegetarian. I do not generally use eggs but compromise every now and then for the children and my husband as they eat eggs, so I did not mind that part.

How I made cream cheese:

I boiled 1 ½ litres of whole milk. I curdled it with 2 cups of fresh curd. Hung the mixture for about 10 mts. to collect the whey. Added a little cream to the residue – the cheese – and beat at high for a minute. When I did not get the desired texture I kneaded it with my fingertips till it was smooth (as for rasgulla or sandesh). I measured and found that I had 3 cups of cream cheese, if this is cream cheese! To my relief I read that cheese cake could be made with paneer also, so I was on a parallel tract if not right!

The cheese cake:

I reduced all other ingredients proportionately. Made a mistake with the vanilla extract – it was a tad more than necessary. I made the cake on my gas the ancient way, as my oven is quite tiny

and it could not take the outer pan.

I kept a regulated temperature using the following arrangement – A heavy tawa or griddle, over that the water bath and the cake! I had to make an approximation about the temperature (I realize I require a few more gadgets if I am to remain a DB!). My cue was the amount of bubbles in the water bath. I just tried to maintain that! I read all about the cares to be taken while preparing a cheese cake on America cooks on the net. It took me about 1 and ¼ hrs. to get a somewhat set cake. The middle was jiggling a little so I removed the cake pan from the water bath and baked it in my oven at the lowest temperature for about 20 minutes. Removed, allowed it to cool completely and transferred it to the fridge for the overnight cooling.

The assemblage:

Again I could not find popsicle sticks – the cylindrical ones. All I found were flat sticks like the ones we use for stick ice creams. I used halved wooden microwave skewers instead and that was just fine. Last night, I removed the cake and felt that the cake had steamed more than necessary! It did not have that soft and moist texture like the cheesecakes I have eaten at bakeries. Anyways I scooped some – had to roll it into balls with my palms and set aside. I cut some into clovers and some into diamonds using cookie cutters – all nearly 2 oz.! I set them again in the fridge for one hour. I thought I had some ribbons for the decoration but couldn’t find any of suitable width so I had to make do with the peppermint balls and almonds I had. I melted the chocolate. Readied some peppermint powder, some almond and raisins powder, and some walnut powder. Removed each popsicle, dipped it half way through into the chocolate dip, and then coated it with one of the powders and set it aside on a greased tray. Set them again in the fridge after taking pictures. This morning I was up earlier than usual, so though it’s a week day I have ample time to take more pics. I tasted a teeny weeny bit but found it had too many eggs for my taste!

I might try the recipe again but not too soon – at least, not until I find readymade ‘creamcheese’!! Till then I will be content that I did not make excuses for the first DB challenge.

For some reason…… probably, because they did not shape so well – the pops reminded me of errant school children – each having his own mind. The two clovers and the one sphere behind them were the goody-goody students, and the rest – well they were all like children who enjoy making the teacher sweat!!

My official guinea pigs’ and their verdict:
After all the above texting, I had to stop to get on with the routine chores. I told my kids about how the pops were behaving like naughty students and that there were only three good ones in my batch! It must have sounded nice because in no time the naughty ones (The ones which were misshapen, or broken) were getting devoured – both my children identified better with naughty ones, I guess! They also carried them to school for short break. Two naughties and one good student!!! My children loved the look, the texture and the description.

Thumbs up for this one, but, not another one till I find ready made cheese cream!!In case I repeat, is it alright to use curd cheese instead of milk cheese? Please gimme your suggestions.

Print Friendly


Have your say

  1. I am very impressed! I can’t believe you made your own cream cheese for this recipe. I don’t think I’d have the patience for that. I wish I could try your cheesecake!

    Great job on the pops. I love the clover shaped ones. This was such a fun challenge, wasn’t it?

  2. these look great 🙂 good job!

  3. Rosa's Yummy Yums




  4. OMG. You made your own cream cheese? How wonderful!! That is taking ‘Daring’ to a whole other level!!

    Anzj from [url=]/Mangerie?![/url]

  5. Wow, you’ve raised the bar with your homemade cream cheese! If next month’s challenge requires that we mill our own flour we’ll know whom to blame 😉

  6. You deserve and award for being faithful and persistent! I can’t believe you made your own cream cheese! You put such effort into the challenge – GREAT JOB!

  7. Passionate baker...& beyond

    Great job on your first challenge my dear…welcome to Daring bakers!It’s always a delight to meet Dbs here in India & a ‘TongueTickler’ is even better!! I made mine with a combination of hung curd which I hung for 24 hours in the fridge & some le bon cottage cheese which I blended with the hung curd. I too have an eggophobia, but to my surprise these were least eggy! They were a HUGE hit! Thanks for stopping by…cheers!

  8. Oh, wow – I can’t believe you made your own cream cheese! True dedication and a wonderful job!!

  9. Thanks all. I still feel the cake steamed through! Did everyone else feel the same? Anyways I am trying another one soon. So I will know then!

  10. The Irreverent Cook

    Oh my, your own cream cheese! Sure sounds like a grand project! Congrats on completing the challenge, they look adorable =)

  11. Congrats on your first challenge..they look are daring to make cream cheese from scratch…love the shapes..

    And you get cream cheese at hypercity mall…

  12. Wow – I am so impressed you made your own cream cheese. These must have tasted so much better knowing that it was truly homemade!

  13. You so totally rock! Making your own cream cheese for this recipe. Wow, I would love to taste your cheesecake. Great job!

    We have a monthly bake along for the Alternative Daring Bakers, contact me if you like to bake with us.

    Natalie @ Gluten a Go Go

  14. The things we take for granted, like cream cheese. I am totally bowing down to you for going through with this and making your own cream cheese. Pretty impressive. The pops look delicious!

  15. All of your pops are so cute and yummy looking! i love the heart shapes~!! I just joined Daring bakers so I will be baking something up next month! yeay!

  16. Hi, thanks for the lovely comments! I am loving it! Havent had the time to check out so many others 🙁

  17. Wow! I can’t believe you made your own cream cheese! Your pops look amazing! Great job!

  18. MyKitchenInHalfCups

    So incredible and a first challenge!
    Made cream cheese in any form is way at the head of the class girl!
    Your pop are then just beautiful!! Really well done and beyond.

  19. Wow, u made the cheese from scratch, great challenge, lovely pops:) keep going…

  20. You are intrepid and dedicated! Nice work.

  21. I am awestruck…you made your own cream cheese! And then make lovely shaped pops. Even the ‘naughty’ ones are great! Congratulations! What a great job on your first challenge. So glad you are a Daring Baker!! Can’t wait to see what you do next month.

  22. wow I’m so impressed that you made your own creamcheese. Your truly a”daring” baker! cute pops!!

  23. Wow! I love the half-dipping to give the varigated finish. You are truly a dedicated cook to make your own creamcheese! Congratulations on your successful outcome!

  24. My goodness, you are a Daring Baker! I really liked your dipping technique with the two-toned effects of the chocolate halfway up the pop.

  25. You MADE cream cheese?!?! I am in awe! I think you should get the “Epitome of a Daring Baker” award for this month!

    I only started DB’s in March so I don’t have any clout, but that’s my suggestion! ;>

  26. Thank you all! I loved hearing from each one of you, and thanks for visiting a new DB….that is so encouraging 🙂

  27. There’s no way I would have attempted to make my own cream cheese – VERY daring!

  28. Great shapes and beautiful pops. Your kids are lovely.

  29. Gretchen Noelle

    I am incredibly impressed by all the steps you went through to accomplish these great pops! Welcome to the Daring Bakers!

  30. Thank you, all! Am looking forward to the next one!

  31. Welcome to the community.
    I wasn’t able to do this challenge but look forward to the next one.
    Great looking cheese pops.

Thanks for reading. Receive free updates by email.

Frank speak corner! Something you would like to say?